AI for Insurance Brokers: Renewals, Quotes and Admin Without the Re-keying
Where AI and automation save a UK broker time, what the FCA is watching, and why small brokers can't afford to sit this one out

Ask a broker where the week goes and you'll hear the same things. Renewals. Chasing clients for information. Keying the same details into three different insurer portals. Explaining a policy wording for the fourth time.
None of that is the reason anyone became a broker, and most of it is the kind of work automation is built for.
Why this matters now for smaller brokers
Brokers know the pressure. In Aviva's Broker Barometer, faster claims settlement (46%) and faster quotes (36%) were the top priorities, with nearly one in three wanting automation to deliver them.
But adoption is patchy. Open GI found as many as 80% of brokers had yet to implement AI, and warned of a gulf between national brokers and smaller regional firms.
And people are hard to find. Talent attraction and retention came out as brokers' biggest priority at this year's BIBA conference. If you can't easily hire, taking the admin off the team you've got is the next best thing.
Where AI genuinely helps a broker
- Renewals. Policies coming up for renewal flagged in good time, the client sent a request for updated information, and their reply logged against the record. No spreadsheet of dates.
- Quote prep. Client details captured once from an email or form and set out ready for each insurer, so nobody retypes them. Some insurer portals have no way in for automation, so we check what's possible before promising anything.
- Policy summaries. A long policy wording turned into a plain-English summary for your team to check before it goes to the client.
- Claims updates. New claims logged, the insurer's updates tracked, and a draft update sitting ready for the handler to send to the client.
- Client chasing. Reminders for missing documents, signed proposals and outstanding premiums, sent on time.
- Inbox sorting. New business, renewals, claims and complaints sorted to the right person as they arrive.
Most of that is automation with AI in the steps that need reading or writing. Same thing in, same thing out, every time.
What the FCA is watching
The FCA named AI as a focus for insurance this year. Its 2026 regulatory priorities for insurance listed AI use in underwriting, claims and consumer services as an area of supervisory focus.
It's not writing new AI rules. The Consumer Duty, the Senior Managers regime and the rest of the existing framework still apply. In its October 2026 good practice publication, the FCA highlighted firms that made it clear to consumers they were using an AI tool, explained what it could and couldn't do, and kept records of what went in and what came out.
That lines up with how I'd set things up anyway:
- Tell people when it's AI. Straight away, with a way to reach a person.
- Keep a record. What the AI was given, what it produced and who checked it.
- Someone owns it. A named person is accountable for how the firm uses AI.
We're not compliance consultants, so check your setup with whoever looks after your compliance. Our job is setting up the tools so a person checks everything before it reaches a client.
What stays human
- The advice. Which cover, which insurer and why. That's what clients pay you for.
- Claims conversations. Someone with a flooded kitchen wants a person, not a bot.
- Complaints. AI can sort a complaint and give you the context. The reply comes from you.
- The relationship. Renewal is where clients decide whether to stay. That call is yours.
Getting found when clients ask AI
There's another side to this. GlobalData's 2026 broker survey says brokers need to stay visible as consumers increasingly use conversational AI to research insurance.
If ChatGPT or Google's AI Mode is asked for a commercial insurance broker in your area, are you in the answer? That's worth checking, and it's something we can help with too.
How we set it up for a broker
- Map the admin. Where your team's time actually goes, and which jobs are worth automating first.
- Connect what you already use. Your inbox, broking system, calendar and document storage wired together in Make, owned by you.
- Set up Claude properly. A business account that doesn't train on your data by default, with Projects for your letters, summaries and house style.
- A human step built in. Anything going to a client or insurer stops in drafts for a person to check.
Most brokers start with a 45-minute session (£150). Builds start from £800, and a Claude Business Setup for the team is £795.
Questions people also ask
How can insurance brokers use AI?
The biggest time savings are in renewals, quote preparation, plain-English policy summaries, claims updates, client chasing and sorting the inbox. Keep the advice, placing decisions, claims conversations and complaints with your team.
Does the FCA allow brokers to use AI?
Yes. The FCA isn't writing AI-specific rules. It expects firms to use AI within the existing framework, including the Consumer Duty and the Senior Managers regime. Its good practice includes telling clients when they're using an AI tool, explaining its limits and keeping records.
Can AI automate insurance renewals?
A lot of the renewal admin can be automated: flagging upcoming renewals, requesting updated information from clients, logging replies and drafting renewal letters. The renewal conversation and recommendation should stay with a broker.
Can automation fill in insurer portals?
Sometimes. It depends on whether the insurer or your broking system offers a way in. Where it doesn't, automation can still capture client details once and lay them out ready to enter, which saves most of the retyping.
Is it safe to use client data with AI tools?
Not in personal or free accounts. Use business plans that don't train on your data by default, check where data is stored and keep to your firm's data protection policy.
How much does it cost?
At Make Automations, a 45-minute session to work out where to start is £150, automation builds start from £800 and a Claude Business Setup for the team is £795.